Weathered brick apartment entrance with paired glazed wood doors, pale limestone trim and tall windows beside a worn concrete sidewalk.

Avenue A Traded Its Coffee Chains for Places That Want You to Stay

At the northwest corner of Avenue A and St. Mark's Place, the windows are covered and the Starbucks sign is gone. As of late September there was no "For Rent" sign in the glass either, EV Grieve reported. Three blocks north, at the southeast corner of 11th Street, a former 7-Eleven now has jewel-toned walls and tucked-away nooks with tufted banquettes. According to EV Grieve's preview of Rabbit Books and Bar, one shelf there is labeled "books too big to fit on our other shelves."

Both changes happened along the same few blocks since mid-August, and they follow a pattern. The places that left Avenue A were built for a quick cup to go. The places opening around them are built to keep the same counter busy from morning coffee to evening drinks.

The Ledger Since August

Here is how the corridor has changed, with the nearest side-street arrival included:

Address Change Timing
149 Avenue A, between Ninth and 10th Blank Street Coffee closed Reported Aug. 21
170 Avenue A, at 11th Rabbit Books and Bar opened Aug. 15
Avenue A and St. Mark's Place, NW corner Starbucks closed Sept. 26
501 E. Sixth St., just east of Avenue A Thone opened Early October
70 Avenue A Barryville General market-cafe soft-opened By Oct. 5; official debut announced for Oct. 16
181 Avenue A, between 11th and 12th Barnes & Noble in build-out November target, possibly later
37 Avenue A, between Second and Third Yamadaya Japanese grocery coming Fall, no date announced
191 Avenue A, at 12th Tipsy Tie Dye studio planned Late fall or early winter

The two closures took the neighborhood's coffee-chain count down further than the avenue alone suggests. The Avenue A shop was the last Blank Street in the East Village. The company's outposts on Third Avenue, on First Avenue and in the Bowery Market were already gone, and the Avenue A location, which opened in November 2021, was the last one left. EV Grieve reported that the lease was up and that management chose not to renew. The Starbucks had opened in August 2017. It closed in the same week Starbucks announced plans to close 250 North American locations, which leaves one Starbucks in the East Village, at First Avenue and Third Street.

Neither space has an announced tenant. The real change on Avenue A is in the newer storefronts and what they do with a full day.

One Counter, Two Shifts

Rabbit Books and Bar is the clearest example. Marianna Vaidman Stone and her daughter, Emily Samara Stone, told EV Grieve they pictured the space as a neighborhood gathering place, inspired in part by Parisian book cafes. They held the grand opening at 8 a.m. on a Saturday. According to Rabbit's own menu, the counter serves coffee, tea, wine, beer, cocktails built on vermouth and soju, pastries and light snacks. That covers a morning coffee and an evening drink in one room, with shelves of international fiction and sci-fi in between, plus "blind date with a book," "not for kids" kids' books and "cats of Tokyo."

The evenings already have a regular calendar. The shop's events page listed an NYU MFA poetry reading on Oct. 25 at 7 p.m. with a two-drink minimum, and a midnight release party for the sixth ACOTAR book the following night. A free Craft + Book Club met there on Oct. 11, combining book discussion with fiber arts. Author Jessica Rao appeared on Oct. 19. Readings, release parties and a book club are the formats to watch for as the November listings go up.

Thone uses the same model half a block off the avenue. The Georgian bakery-cafe and natural-wine bar sits next to Corner Bistro at 501 E. Sixth St. It serves coffee, pastries and traditional Georgian breads in the morning, then switches to wine and snacks around 5 p.m., and it is open 8 a.m. to midnight daily. A staffer told EV Grieve the name reflects an accessible neighborhood anchor, budget-friendly and meant for everyday drop-ins rather than special occasions.

Further south, Barryville General took an existing Avenue A business and added a daytime layer. Co-owner Sean Naughton and co-founder Eric Komovoff expanded the shop at 70 Avenue A with a market-cafe selling coffee, baked goods and pantry items. It was in soft-open mode by early October, with an official debut announced for Oct. 16.

Rabbit, Thone and Barryville are each owner-run, and each puts coffee at the start of a longer day rather than selling it as a single transaction. The two closed chain shops made coffee the whole business.

The Chain on Its Way Sells Books Without Coffee

The one national retailer heading to Avenue A takes the opposite approach. Barnes & Noble is building out 181 Avenue A, between 11th and 12th streets. It will be the first retail tenant in the base of the Steiner East Village condo, and the shop sits about a block from Rabbit's door. EV Grieve's Oct. 26 update found plenty of shelving installed. The company's website says the store will open in November, but employees on site said it could take another month or two.

Readers had been asking whether the store would have a cafe, and management has now answered it. There will be no cafe.

By early winter, then, the 11th-to-12th Street stretch of Avenue A should have two bookstores. The national one is built around browsing and buying. The independent one is built around staying, with a drink menu and a reading calendar. Anyone who wants a coffee and a chapter at a table near Tompkins Square will still find it at the independent shops, as they have since August.

Tipsy Tie Dye, planned for 191 Avenue A at 12th Street, points the same way. The sip-and-style studio is aiming for late fall or early winter, with a beer-and-wine license alongside daytime activities. Smaller changes are moving in the same direction. The flower stand outside Key Food at Avenue A and Fourth Street reopened under a new team after a short renovation. Meanwhile, the Dollar Pizza at 131 Avenue A closed earlier in the summer.

Tompkins Square Is Being Rebuilt on a Longer Clock

The new storefronts are betting that people will spend hours on Avenue A, and the park across the street is getting investment on a timeline of years. On Oct. 3, the city's fifth annual City of Forest Day, Tompkins Square Park got a new mini forest along Seventh Street between Avenues A and B. It was part of a larger round of planting that also added new trees and a rain garden.

The worn paths are next. At Community Board 3's parks committee meeting on Oct. 15, Steve Simon, chief of staff for the Parks Department's Manhattan borough office, said funding secured through Councilmember Harvey Epstein will pay for path repairs, with work likely to start on the west side. That is the Avenue A side. Simon also confirmed money is in the budget to redo the Ninth Street transverse, the east-west path through the park. That project had been planned years ago and was postponed while the field house was built, a project completed in April 2025. No exact start date was given. A slide shown at the meeting had the paths "completed by 2028" and synthetic turf in the large dog run next year, according to EV Grieve's account of the meeting. The dog-run turf project appears on the NYC Parks capital project tracker.

The park's busiest weekly event doesn't stop for winter. The Tompkins Square Greenmarket runs year-round on Sundays from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m. at Avenue A and Seventh Street. Compost drop-off runs 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., and clothing collection runs 9 a.m. to 1 p.m.

A November Sunday, South to North

One way to use the avenue as it stands now, from Third Street up to 12th:

  1. Yamadaya, 37 Avenue A. Check the signage between Second and Third streets on your way past. The Japanese grocery has announced a fall opening but no date.
  2. Barryville General, 70 Avenue A. Coffee and a baked good from the new market-cafe, plus pantry items for later in the week.
  3. Thone, 501 E. Sixth St. A short detour east for Georgian bread to bring home. Come back after 5 p.m. for wine.
  4. Tompkins Square Greenmarket, Avenue A and Seventh Street. Drop off compost, shop the stands, then walk past the new mini forest along the Seventh Street edge.
  5. Rabbit Books and Bar, 170 Avenue A. Browse the shelves, take a banquette, and stay for whatever reading or club is on the calendar that evening.
  6. 181 Avenue A. Look in at the Barnes & Noble build-out a block north to see whether the November target holds.

If you want to stay out after dark, La MaMa's Spiderwoman's Global Indigenous Theatre Festival runs through Nov. 7, and the theater's Puppet Festival starts Nov. 11, opening with Endless Forms from Nov. 11 to 14.

Tracking which tenants arrive on a corridor, and what hours they keep, shapes how we price and present homes across Manhattan and Brooklyn. If you own near Avenue A and want to know how the corridor's new tenants affect the way buyers will see your building, Luxury Alliance Team can walk the blocks with you. Schedule a consultation.

Work With Us

Follow Me on Instagram